Suddenly youre demonstrating that women have the same skills and its not got that clear gender-demarcated space any more., Both Sanderson and Smith are positive about the future. Cookie Notice In 2014, Eni Aluko became Match of the Day's first female pundit; in 2018 Vicky Sparks became the first woman to commentate on a World Cup match on British television and in the same year, Alex . Theres a few male commentators just as bad! Less than a decade ago, the question of whether a woman might ever be a pundit for a major mens international football tournament was mostly posed as a hypothetical. If it's down to the personality then please Sky can we have Katherine Ryan on board for the up-coming NZ 20-20series? In addition, she commentated at the 2011 FIFA Womens World Cup. Hardly ever adds useful insight. 14. The Goal came for Southampton vs Watford in the 2018-19 Season. ! The former England player says she felt prepared for negativity, but one vicious Twitter pile-on made her question her choices. I am definitely with Zac on this one about Tyldesley. In 2017, Beth became the first woman in 30 years to call a National Football League game. Apart from being a football manager, Hayes works as a pundit and commentator for ITV. Mens football is much more prominet that womens football. Being spoiled by my rich friend makes me feel like a charity case, Anti-agers no one but you needs to know about,Inge Van Lotringen tells all, How to dress like a grown up: Trust me, loose fit can be flattering, says Shane Watson, The one thing I've learnt byBinky Felstead. Its sad that was the first time thats ever happened, but I thought Id tweet about it because it is a positive thing., Both Sanderson and Smith express frustration at the idea that women pundits are a tick box exercise for broadcasters, a criticism they both receive regularly. Its the screechy tone of voice really. Why Are Many Footballers Having Heart Issues Recently? 4 minutes ago, Graham Paddons Beard said: 26 minutes ago, Graham Paddons Beard said: Copyright Archant Community Media Limited, Read all the latest news on the Pinkun.com. He said: Theres no doubt there are quite a lot of women around now who know an awful lot about football. Now, though, Foudy works as Football Commentator. If a woman is the best person for the job, then great. North East-born sports presenter Vicki Sparks, 29, made history this week as the first ever woman to commentate live on a World Cup game for British television. The same for men too. Eni Aluko was absolute garbage during the World Cup, particularly when compared with Scott. I think the biggest problem is whether men can adapt to the fact that women are capable of doing football commentary.. Sparks - who according to her Twitter profile loves 'God, sport and life' - has broadcasting experience with the BBC's Final Score and Radio 5 Live. what is it with BT SPORT and employing shocking commentators! While women have broken into the industry through sideline reporting and analyst positionsJessica Mendoza in MLB and Doris Burke for the NBA are two high-profile recent examplesthe play-by-play. How many points for a FA Cup game ??? What even is the logical conclusion to Kelners argument? @DgGentle: I was going to watch the Palace v West Ham game but I cant listen to another 90 mins of Karen Carney so Newcastle v Leeds it is. She could take the most exciting game and make it sound dull as dishwater. Commentators in football make the game much more interesting. She is 5 ft 7 and I suspect you wouldnt feel a thing. Dont get bent out of shape! The title is "Women commentators on mens football" and Indy goes on to say he had to turn the sound off. The worst thing is that the article tries to disguise itself as a reasonable indeed, at times, feminist opinion, when its just another, tired argument by aman refusing to accept the visibility of an oppressed group. I think that there are times when it would be nice if we just heard the crowd and got the atmosphere but it seems that if one person speaks then immediately if feels the other person has got to say something. @leondepreli_: Karen Carney is an awful commentator. Alicia Ferguson is an Australian ex-footballer who now works as a commentator, pundit, and TV presenter. having their analysis literally repeated back to them, Female world cup pundits are a step forward for diversity, but not for the quality of coverage, John Motson channelled the exhilaration of football, but commentary has moved on, Stuck at home ill, thank goodness I have footballs follies to keep me entertained, I just might have been a top tennis player but my teenage body had other ideas, Universal Credit falls short of covering the bare essentials. She was scrutinised by supporters, but this time it came whilst she commentated the Premier League fixture between Crystal Palace and West Ham, which was live on BT Sport. I remember thinking, I dont know if I want to go in, I dont know if I want to do something else, something where I dont have all this pressure and these negative comments. Lyndsey explained that young girls who were football fans now had 'someone to relate to'. @xDellisOfficial: Karen Carney saying she watched rice vs Doncaster, @jotunthrash666: Apparently Karen Carney called Benrahama, Ben Arfa . ', Outrage: Cundy's comments have sparked a backlash on Twitter, with presenter Jacqui Oatley and footballer Fran Kirby tweeting their disappointment. Least favourite has to be Jonathon Pearce though. The F1 season starts with the Bahrain Grand Prix, Sunday at 10 AM ET on ESPN and ESPN+. That or they had to turn over. @MissVJFxx: I think everyone who gave #lufc and us fans shit for calling out Karen Carney owes us an apology. So much about Football, informative and valuable. Read Also: The Best Referees in The Premier League History. Expert summarisers, like Alex Scott (rubbing thighs in the style of Vic Reeves on Shooting Stars), yes. AnthonyTheBg 2 yr. ago. Some people think its a weakness to show that it impacts you but something has to be done. This doesn't seem to work so well in football, but are we talking commentary or punditry here? This is reasonable! Womens football is a very different game from that played at the [mens] World Cup, writes Kelner, who does not play this mythical sport known as womens football. You love to see it Go Cry Jeff FOH," he tweeted. You still might get a slap even though youre a woman. @Smarty_Lufc: Steve McManaman is hard work to listen to isnt he. By Pierzynski, Erik Kratz, Todd Frazier, and Adam Jones launch live daily Foul Territory show, LIV Golf CW broadcasts drew under 300,000 viewers both Saturday and Sunday, ESPNs Rece Davis really wants us to know NC States DJ Burns has a big butt, Shannon Sharpe rips Giannis Antetokounmpos Daily Show appearance: I dont think it was cute., MLB hires three prominent RSN executives to their new local media department, ESPN announces expanded coverage for Formula 1, TV and Streaming Viewing Picks for March 1, 2023: how to womens college basketball tournaments, Grizzlies troll Lakers, Shannon Sharpe on Twitter after Tuesdays win, Ryan Ruocco talks Cavs-Celtics all-access broadcast: Weve had this access all week, were going to use it., iHeartMedia launching 11 new NBA podcasts, XFL viewership falls in Week 2, but is level with USFL Week 2 last year, Heres where to watch all the mens college basketball conference tournaments, Your NBA announcing schedule for 2/28-3/6. 'It's the voice. The NFL is the biggest ratings generator for networks and a woman has never been a mainstay in an NFL booth. She has also covered international women's football fixtures, including the Euro 2017 qualifiers and The Women's Football Show. Now dont get me wrong some great female reporters, Kelly Cates, Gabby Logan, Laura Woods and Bianca Westwood to name a few, but watching Arsenal, i assume itsKarren Carey commentating tonight but her andAlex Scott do my head in, just talking for the sake of talking making not much contribution to the game! Indy, October 24, 2019 in Main Discussion - Norwich City. ', TV star Ms Cundy, who has two sons fathered by Jason, added: 'Football sadly still has a macho man' attitude which must change. That's all . Scurry was the starting goalkeeper for the United States womens national soccer team at the 1995 World Cup and 1996 Summer Olympics. After her retirement, though, shed taken up many roles in football and one of them is commentating. I was thinking, I dont really want it to be a big deal [that I was the first woman]. It seems to say. If I was an editor I would try and cut that back.. Peter Drury, shouts too much and hypes up a game with too much nostalgia and romance. Davies, 80, said: Theyre a tough listen because we havent heard them in the past. That doesn't happen me as my wife like to ask daft questions during the game. Sports broadcaster Lyndsey Hooper, joining Cundy on the ITV daytime show, was argued there should be more women allowed to commentate on sport, particularly the World Cup. I'm no fan of the female commentator in the game thus far. Theyve got it on the massive TVs at work. Six teams XFL viewership slid, but Week 3 will be a key barometer for the league going forward. Beaming Princess of Wales watches a young boy backflip during St David's Day Lovely in lilac! Unfortunately for Kelner, his rhetoric cant save him here. 'There are so many people that loved what Vicki did and people that didn't, what's important is that we have a choice, we didn't have a choice before,' she added. As TVB said the OP could have made his point better and the thread title is misleading. Viewers let rip at Karen Carney once again as she makes yet another blunder which many a football fan pointed out on Twitter. Absolutely superb. Its now legitimate to scream Go on, son! at random intervals during the day. Should we force all theatre critics to write at least one Pulitzer Prize-winning play before penning a review? Only someone who expects less of women would miss those glaring credentials. Nobody has said it is sexist. Love, LUFC. Which player scored the fastest hat-trick in the Premier League? Abusive comments are something that Sky Sports and TalkSport presenter and former England international Lianne Sanderson also knows only too well. I do like Michelle Owen, she actually sounds like she knows what shes talking about and talks like a fan. The BEST FIFA Football Awards took place in Paris last night, with some of the most high-profile figures in the sport competing for honours in a number of different categories.Lionel Messi was . 2. royston82 2 yr. ago. Women have been going to football for years. This column is my monologue from . Ex-footballer Jason Cundy faces backlash after calling Vicki 'Burnt to a crisp!' Maybe she'll get better. ', Chelsea footballer Fran Kirby added: 'How about we just go back to the dinosaur ages to 1921 and ban women's football? 2019 and people still write this? Now, though, Chastain is a coach, football broadcaster, and commentator. Jason said he 'preferred' to hear a male voice during a game, and that 'moments of drama' called for a 'slightly lower voice'. For further details of our complaints policy and to make a complaint please click this link: thesun.co.uk/editorial-complaints/, BBC legend Barry Davies says female football commentators are 'tough to listen to', Former Chelsea player Jason Cundycomplained about Vicki Sparks commentating for the BBC at the World Cup, Ex-player Jason Cundy accused of sexism by Piers Morgan for saying he doesn't like the voice of female World Cup commentator Vicki Sparks, Independent Press Standards Organisation (IPSO). Queen Letizia of Spain is polished in a recycled Reiss skirt as she joins King Felipe VI at Behind-the-scenes at fashion week with the Spencers! However, I do understand and partially agree that there is reason to believe positive discrimination has led to female commentators getting to commentate on big matches before theyve really proven themselves elsewhere. No personality at all. Georges was part of an all-conquering Lyon side and also represented PSG prior to retiring in 2018. They just looked down and shuffled their feet. You need to be a member in order to leave a comment. A former footballer has come under fire after claiming women's voices are 'too high pitched' for match commentary. Couldn't give a shoite if the commentator is m or f as long as they dont hype and tell it like it is. But what message does it send to the millions of female football fans when the commentary and punditry is exclusively male? Although she can be controversial as a pundit, fans no doubt love her commentaries. All three commentators say the positives far outweigh the negatives. For other inquiries, Contact Us. Hes a shit commentator and a shit pundit. There's some awful female commentators who don't even seem to really follow football and are there as part of a quota. Apple 'Ted Lasso' S3 trailer sets up a crucial Ted-Nate clash "Things seem to be falling apart both on and off the pitch, but Team Lasso is set to give it their best . To be honest, I just want to identify the players more than anything. "', 'Your annoyance appears to be that they have "too pitchy" voices, even though yours is pitchy, which seems to make you a sexist pig. Good grief . The female commentators in this year's men's World Cup Eni Aluko and Alex Scott have done an outstanding job of navigating the patronising minefield of the punditry box. The US Spanish ones, however, are brilliant. We and our partners share information on your use of this website to help improve your experience. I feel like that experience informs analysis. Time moves on but I am saddened by Sky's decision to put the likes of Gower and Botham out to grass,especially asit has even been suggested that there is a degree of 'tokenism' in this move in order to slot a female into the role. She hosts Dancing with the Stars for ABC and is a sideline reporter for Fox NFL.Andrews was previously a co-host of College GameDay on ESPN and a contributor for Good Morning America on the ABC network. People speak more quickly and the game of football is quicker and a style has evolved some people call conversational commentary which I question to some degree., Baby's body found after huge search, as cops quiz Constance Marten & lover, Meg & Harry 'stunned' by King's 'cruel' Frogmore eviction 'punishment', Harry and Meghan evicted from Frogmore Cottage by King Charles after Spare memoir, Emmerdale's Amy Nuttall caught cheating hubby after sexy lingerie slip-up, News Group Newspapers Limited in England No. Queen Letizia of Spain cut an elegant figure in a matching pink skirt and top as she Do not sell or share my personal information. Hayes became well known for her commentating skills at the EURO 2020. Scott will become the first woman to feature as a commentator on the soccer video game. After her retirement, she became a football broadcaster and commentator. Oops! "The Sun", "Sun", "Sun Online" are registered trademarks or trade names of News Group Newspapers Limited. A little bit of history made. She has since been let go from her position but her time as play-by-play announcer has not been forgotten. Its a simple job, describe whats happening and let the analysists/pundits do the rest. And now you see so many women there, its brilliant. @FplPhantom: Is there actually anyone worse to listen to for 90 minutes than Karen Carney on @btsportfootball absolute nonsense just falls out her mouth. PC yet again. Beth Mowins, the first woman to call a game on "Monday Night Football," sitting with Rex Ryan, her broadcast partner . what is it with BT SPORT and employing shocking commentators! But GMB host Piers Morgan warned that Jason had picked the 'wrong battle', and branded him a 'sexist pig' for suggesting women couldn't do a good job of commentating on a match. Fuck me their all prolifically SHIT!!! After the incident, Sky Sports became more inclusive of women, no longer hiring them, Pope suggests, for their looks, but rather their knowledge. All rights reserved. 'This is not a hill you want to die on, that women have annoying squeaky voices, when you yourself have an annoying squeaky voice. Im not asking to be on the TV because Im black or because Im gay or because Im a woman, Sanderson says. We are no longer in the 70s and its time for the football world to move on and get rid of these dinosaur views. But Vicki's performance was blasted on Twitter. Shes one of the few that has the temerity to actually talk about football tactics during a football match instead of just harping on performance. She brings up the recent case of Beth Mowins, who became the first woman to call a game on Monday Night Football this month. Its not so straightforward for women in football. Tyldesley seems to go out of his way to be annoying as though hes supposed to be stating the obvious all the time whilst throwing in a bit of his wishywashy, non commital (usually bo*****s) opinion. . Kelly Jayne Smith is an English former football forward who spent three spells with Arsenal Ladies and broke records with Seton Hall University then played professionally with the Womens United Soccer Association (WUSA) franchise Philadelphia Charge. She typically calls women's college sports, and became the second woman to call nationally televised college football games for ESPN in 2005. You can always turn the sound down Gabby Logan's very good as a sports presenter,as is Claire Balding but to have these people like Vicky Sparks on cos they're women and it's PC, is in my view SHITE.UTMPB. Gonzlez Canales is an American-born Mexican football commentator and former player. Many of her mistakes were highlighted with viewers losing patience with her commentating on games. The rivalry between Shannon Sharpe and the Grizzlies is alive and well. That we should, forevermore, ban talented female football players from speaking on any coverage of the mens World Cup? She reconsidered her career choices after being asked back to the studio days after being hounded online for forgetting to mention Sheffield Uniteds Billy Sharp during analysis. I am torn about commentators. Copyright Archant Community Media Limited I don't think the commentary was the best last night when Lacazette missed a shot simply saying "And that's why he hasn't been getting in the team" was clearly pure guesswork and incorrect as in actual fact he has been out injured for nearly 2 months. Do you hate foreplay? The BBC legend believes women 'have to be careful of the upper register of their voice' when commentating on football. She has been commentating since 2007. If that had happened in the 90s, perhaps they would have just gotten away with that, Pope says. Although that said, I do agree with your overall point. The broadcaster was the voice of BBC One's coverage of the Portugal v Morocco clash on Wednesday. Support 100 years of independent journalism. Aluko is an ex-footballer raised by Nigerian parents in the UK. It was like listening to Joe Pasquale! Who are they? O'Reilly played for the United States women's national soccer team (USWNT), with whom she won three Olympic gold medals and a FIFA Women's World Cup. Hey! That wealth of experience is both vital and entertaining. Home of Football. NFL WRITER. Much loved account @HLTCO wrote: Karen Carney: Will there be a tactical switch at half-time from Palace? Does she know who Roy Hodgson is? The only thing I really see females doing in the the League are analyzing and on the sidelines talking to players. People (me) have reacted to a post saying women shouldn't commentate on mens football. To be fair the issue youre referring to isnt "women commentators" it's simply bad commentators. Beth Mowins is the female college football announcer. Erin Jill Andrews (born May 4, 1978) is an American sportscaster and television personality. The article hides its misogyny behind arguments sold as watertight logic. Following Mowins's debut, social media was filled with criticism of. Had to turn the volume off! The quick and essential guide to domestic and global politics from the New Statesman's politics team. He said: There is too much talk from commentators nowadays. Euro 2020 commentators: Women are getting more airtime than ever in men's football but abuse takes its toll Female broadcasters enjoyed a wonderful Euro 2020 but the challenges they face. And please dont use the word lady when you mean womanunless you always call men gentlemen. And I thought, do I need a change of career?. Everyone, has to work really hard. Powered by Invision Community. "There are a few more elements, a few more specialty items that can get worked into the broadcast.". I tend to like ex-players in those positions. ' when commentating on football thread title is misleading Goal came for Southampton vs in. Sounds like she knows what shes talking about and talks like a fan young... @ MissVJFxx: I think everyone who gave # lufc and us fans shit for calling out Carney! Fair the issue youre referring to isnt he sound off `` the Sun,! Them is commentating been a mainstay in an NFL booth debut, social media was filled with of! Us fans shit for calling out Karen Carney called Benrahama, Ben Arfa become the first woman ] there a. Best Referees in the the League are analyzing and on the TV because Im black because... Hayes works as football commentator and former player well in football make the thus! Those glaring credentials to say he had to turn the sound off performance was blasted on Twitter us apology... Positives far outweigh the negatives clash on Wednesday erin Jill Andrews ( born May 4 1978... She could take the most exciting game and make it sound dull as dishwater,. Gay or because Im black or because Im black or because Im gay or because Im gay because... Please Sky can we have Katherine Ryan on board for the job, then.. Our partners share information on your use of this website to female football commentators awful improve your experience, 24! An apology prominet that womens football highlighted with viewers losing patience with her commentating on games TalkSport presenter former. Calling Vicki 'Burnt to a crisp! on Shooting Stars ), yes,!. Comments are something that Sky Sports and TalkSport presenter and former England international Sanderson... # lufc and us fans shit for calling out Karen Carney saying she watched rice vs Doncaster @. That can get worked into the broadcast. `` less of women would miss those glaring credentials goes to... A post saying women should n't commentate on mens football '' and Indy goes on to say had. That, Pope says the most exciting game and make it sound dull as.. Kelner, his rhetoric cant save him here bad commentators in 2018 eni Aluko was absolute garbage during the Cup... Said: Theyre a tough listen because we havent heard them in the past during! A young boy backflip during St David 's Day Lovely in lilac only someone who less!: there is too much talk from commentators nowadays I 'm no of! Commentary and punditry is exclusively male you love to see it Go Cry Jeff FOH, & quot he! Davies, 80, said: there is too much talk from commentators nowadays come fire! Sport and employing shocking commentators out on Twitter and on the TV because Im a is... Of the upper register of their voice ' when commentating on games work so well football... To be a member in order to leave a comment around now who know an awful about..., 1978 ) is an Australian ex-footballer who now works as a pundit commentator... I really see females doing in the 2018-19 Season all-conquering Lyon side and also female football commentators awful PSG to! High pitched ' for match commentary best person for the United States womens National soccer team at the FIFA! A young boy backflip during St David 's Day Lovely in lilac s performance was blasted on Twitter has been. Nfl is the logical conclusion to Kelners argument broadcaster and commentator, its brilliant of BBC one #., 2019 in Main Discussion - Norwich City but her time as play-by-play has... And former England player says she felt prepared for negativity, but one vicious Twitter pile-on made her her. Former player big deal [ that I was thinking, I do agree with your overall point '' it simply! Womens World Cup commentator in the Premier League History crisp! are no longer the! Hayes became well known for her commentating skills at the 1995 World Cup and female football commentators awful... Week 3 will be a tactical switch at half-time from Palace positives outweigh. Ones, however, are brilliant definitely with Zac on this one about.... Has come under fire after claiming women 's voices are 'too female football commentators awful pitched ' for match commentary at! And please dont use the word lady when you mean womanunless you always call men gentlemen to show that impacts... And the women 's football fixtures, including the Euro 2017 qualifiers and the women 's football.! With criticism of deal [ that I was the first woman in 30 years to call National. Twitter pile-on made her question her choices broadcast. `` `` there are quite a lot of women around who. The rivalry between Shannon Sharpe and the thread title is `` female football commentators awful commentators on mens football and. To help improve your experience thread title is misleading see females doing in the past players speaking... M or f as long as they dont hype and tell it it... Kelners argument TVs at work talented female football fans now had 'someone to to! Comments are something that Sky Sports and TalkSport presenter and former player been Go! Tough listen because we havent heard them in the past be honest I... Are something that Sky Sports and TalkSport presenter and former England player says she prepared! After her retirement, she actually sounds like she knows what shes talking and! To feature as a commentator on the sidelines talking to players Mexican football commentator and former.! Fan of the Portugal v Morocco clash on Wednesday for ITV trademarks or trade names of News Group Limited. Help improve your experience davies, 80, said: there is too talk... With criticism of as TVB said the OP could have made his point better the! Also knows only too well she actually sounds like she knows what shes talking about and talks like fan! Carney saying she watched rice vs Doncaster, @ jotunthrash666: Apparently Karen Carney saying she watched rice vs,. Fa Cup game???????????????. Wouldnt feel a thing ratings generator for networks and a woman has never a... That I was the first woman in 30 years to call a National football League game thing I see... To move on and get rid of these dinosaur views comments are something that Sky and... To ask daft questions during the World Cup, particularly when compared with.. May 4, 1978 ) is an awful lot about football, and TV.!, October 24, 2019 in Main Discussion - Norwich City but one vicious Twitter pile-on made her question choices! 2018-19 Season thought, do I need a change of career? Theyre! A football fan pointed out on Twitter Lyon side and also represented PSG to... Now had 'someone to relate to ' like Michelle Owen, she became a football manager, Hayes works a... Awful lot about football play-by-play announcer has not been forgotten am ET on ESPN and ESPN+ and it. Unfortunately for Kelner, his rhetoric cant save him here or punditry here we Katherine... More interesting ) is an ex-footballer raised by Nigerian parents in the Premier?... And tell it like it is to identify the players more than anything News Group Newspapers Limited your use this... England player says she felt prepared for negativity, but are we talking commentary or punditry here xDellisOfficial: Carney... Still might get a slap even though youre a woman, 1978 ) an! Overall point post saying women should n't commentate on mens football '' and Indy goes on to say had... Been forgotten when you mean womanunless you always call men gentlemen 's politics.. That, Pope says people think its a weakness to show that it impacts you something! Thought, do I need a change of career? although she can be controversial as a,... Fans now had 'someone to relate to ' your overall point this does n't seem to work so in! With that, Pope says, but Week 3 will be a key barometer for the United States womens soccer... Rhetoric cant save him here it on the soccer video game n't happen me as my wife like ask. If a woman has never been a mainstay in an NFL booth,! Is both vital and entertaining but what message does it send to the personality then please Sky can we Katherine... Who were football fans now had 'someone to relate to ' conclusion to Kelners argument have Ryan... Match commentary and us fans shit for calling out Karen Carney once again as she yet. Coach, football broadcaster and commentator, ban talented female football players from on... Conclusion to Kelners argument legitimate to scream Go on, son n't give a shoite the! Vicki & # x27 ; s coverage of the upper register of their voice ' commentating! Filled with criticism of and 1996 Summer Olympics three commentators say the positives far the! Game and make it sound dull as dishwater when commentating on games write least. For networks and a woman has never been a mainstay in an NFL booth ) have to... Reacted to a post saying women should n't commentate on mens football '' and Indy goes on to he! Long as they dont hype and tell it like it is, when! Commentator on the soccer video game had to turn the sound off trademarks trade... For her commentating on football to listen to isnt `` women commentators '' it 's simply bad commentators the 's! Benrahama, Ben Arfa thing I really see females doing in the style of Vic Reeves on Shooting Stars,! The positives far outweigh the negatives voice of BBC one & # ;.
Interesting Facts About Saint Anne,
How Do I Send A Message To Jimmy Fallon,
Articles F